BullionStar Blogs

Inside BullionStar

Posted on 16 Feb 2016 by BullionStar

Oil & US Dollar & Gold

In the midst of upwards trending oil prices a decade ago, a US senate committee recommended actions to curb the high oil price to mitigate the negative effect on growth.

Ok, great, the oil price went from north of USD 140 in 2008 to around USD 30 now.

But now, mainstream economists are disappointed that the sliding oil price hasn’t had much positive effect on growth and instead tell us that a decreasing oil price is a double-edged sword at best and a threat to the US economy at worst. This despite the US being a net importer of oil, importing about 20 % of its oil consumption.

oil production US

Source: Cornucopia

According to most mainstream economists, a fall in prices, oftentimes mislabelled as deflation, is a horrific thing that must be avoided at all costs.

Before countering the deflation scare, let us first establish that deflation by definition is a shrinkage in the money supply whereas price deflation is the resulting effect of the general price level for goods and services when the money supply decreases.

The mainstream economist argument is that price deflation is bad because people are said to hold off consumption anticipating even lower prices in the future. Really?

Do people hold off their oil consumption because of falling prices? Do people hold off their consumption of food if prices are anticipated to fall? Are people waiting to buy a mobile phone if the price of the product is anticipated to decrease in the future?

Global oil production has increased, with a corresponding price decrease, in recent years due to innovative technological advancements.

The decreasing price of oil is, despite its negative short-term effects on the producers, a positive event enabling the economy to operate more efficiently. Less resources and costs are needed to produce and consume 1 litre of oil today compared to a year ago. The resources liberated from the increased efficiency can instead be put into something else and thus increase productivity further.

US Dollar

We already know that the banking system is inherently incentivizing reckless debt behaviour to the extent that banks have got to increase their balance sheet continuously, for the fractional reserve based monetary system not to collapse.

Savings used to be the backbone of an economy. With savings, it was possible to accumulate capital used for investments. Nowadays, savings has nothing to do with investing as the money is simply created out of thin air as debt by commercial banks and called capital.

Today, debt, and particularly US Dollar denominated debt, is used as a store of value around the world. This skews everything.

A strong US Dollar is to be expected in such a system.

The US Dollar will continue to strengthen until… it collapses.

The US has been running a trade deficit for some four decades by now and has in the process accumulated a humongous national debt.

How is that even possible?

According to Economics 101, the currency of a country running perpetual trade deficits is supposed to depreciate to balance the trade. With a depreciating currency, imports will be more expensive and exports will be cheaper for others to buy. The trade deficit will thus decrease.

This doesn’t happen in the US though. Why?

The reason is that the value of the US Dollar, functioning as a reserve currency, is dictated by the (savings) demand for the US Dollar in the rest of the world. The US doesn’t have a choice on whether to run a trade imbalance or not. It’s the net producing countries (read China) exporting to the consuming countries (read USA) that is dictating to what extent the US can utilize the exorbitant privilege of issuing debt in the world’s reserve currency.

It’s the demand of the US Dollar as a reserve currency that sets the pace. For the US Dollar to function as a reserve currency, the US is required to run trade deficits for the purpose of distributing US Dollars to the net producers/savers.

When savers save in the same medium as is used for the Medium of Exchange, a collapse always follows the monetary expansion when the debt savings are undone. The trigger point of this may very well be when the flow of physical gold dries up. Freegold is instructive in explaining the mechanism that is likely to correct the current imbalance between the paper world and physical world.

The Prudence of Saving in Gold

Following a collapse of our monetary system, it will be vital to own gold as a store of value. Paper assets will no longer matter. For us to get a glimpse at life beyond this transition, India may provide a good example since basically the whole population are avid gold savers.

In India, people have protected their wealth with gold over generations. For Indians, gold is an asset class that bridges inequalities by giving individuals a shot at protecting themselves against foolish government policies. The government does everything in their power, with the Indian trade deficit as their go to excuse, to have people surrendering their gold. The government has introduced a gold monetization scheme, there’s gold import duties, documentation requirements for buying gold and campaigns to convince people to open bank accounts.

Who’s right? The government or the people?

Let’s compare the track record of the Indian Rupee versus Gold. At the start of 1960, 1 gram of gold cost 5.37 Indian Rupees. On 1 February 2016, 1 gram of gold cost 2,443.59 Indian Rupees excluding the premium stemming from the 10 % import duty. The Indian Rupee as measured in gold has thus lost about 99.8 % of its value since 1960.

Indians don’t expect the government to take care of you from cradle to grave, they realise that they need to save to educate their children and to look after their aging parents and themselves when retiring.

Isn’t the world upside down when prudent savers have to fight the government’s reckless policies to keep their wealth?

When fiat money hyper-inflates, paper gains or paper deficits will no longer matter. Owning physical gold will.

E-mail BullionStar on:

  • Reynold Rego

    The Fed is worried about negative interest rates in the U.S economy as lower prices could lead to deflation. Deflation can also lower GDP growth. 3 quarters of negative GDP
    growth is recession. The U.S economy could slip into recession in late 2016 or early 2017.

    Crude oil is traded in U.S. dollars and that creates demand for the U.S. dollar (petro-dollar), irrespective of the U.S. trade deficits. wait… China is on track to establish crude benchmark in Yuan. Eventually, they will buy oil from Middle East in Yuan. that will reduce petro-dollar demand.

    India’s black money is trapped in its real estate and gold. As far as the Indian gold monetization scheme is concerned, the government’s objective could be something else. I see this as a repetition of Indian Gold Control Act 1968. Initially, the government will voluntarily tell people to monetize gold and then…

    • Thank you for your comment Reynold,
      I don’t really believe it’s the trading of oil priced and transacted in the USD that props up the USD. If that were to be true, the drop in oil prices would have had a bigger effect on the USD.

      Instead, I’m of the opinion that it’s the US Dollars reserve currency status where USD debt is saved is a store of value by savers (and surplus countries although this is reversing) that props up the USD.

      There’s many developing markets and currencies crashing currently which has been the last fragile thread for the USD to hold onto as entities in those countries are running towards the USD. When savings are undone and this trend reverse, the USD is done.

      • Reynold Rego

        yes, you are right. the USD debt is saved as a store of value by savers.

        The U.S. did a very very smart thing. They ensured that the countries that export goods to them (China, Saudi Arabia) buy U.S. debt. Eventually, export oriented countries like China ended up buying U.S. debt from the USD that they earned.
        In February 2009, Hillary Clinton pleaded China to continue to buy U.S. Treasuries. She said ” We are truly going to rise and fall together. Our economies are so intertwined..”

        It is like me telling you to issue a loan of 100 million USD and in return i will buy goods worth 100 million USD from you. i also promise you to pay interest on the loan. so i contribute to your business sales and the loan you issued me is your investments on which you earn interest. Since, i am your biggest client, you won’t hesitate to issue me more loan in return of more business but they day i am in trouble, you are in a very big trouble. This is what is happening with China. They want to avoid a future problem and started dumping U.S treasuries and using the USD to defend the Yuan. As China moves from export driven to consumption based economy, the Yuan peg to USD will go and they will reduce holdings in U.S debt.

        The U.S. dollar is safe so long as the U.S can find a buyer of its debt in return of business.

  • Sean Swann

    Yuan Gold Standard and Ruble Gold Standard are coming…. RUSSIA CHINA IRAN trade oil in rub,rmb,€, not dollars. And Iran Completes Eurasian Golden Triangle, Oil and Gold is going Up ! IMHO,

  • I think gold is a great a investment but i prefer silver over gold actually because i think silver has more room to grow than gold.. But both has an excellent hedge against inflation.

  • KhushKumar


    Equity tips

  • Harish

    p { margin-bottom: 0.25cm; line-height: 120%; }a:link { }

    cash tips Awesome blog

Copyright Information: BullionStar permits you to copy and publicize blog posts or quotes and charts from blog posts provided that a link to the blog post's URL or to https://www.bullionstar.com is included in your introduction of the blog post together with the name BullionStar. The link must be target="_blank" without rel="nofollow". All other rights are reserved. BullionStar reserves the right to withdraw the permission to copy content for any or all websites at any time.